Collin Value

3908 Nightingale St, Celina, TX 75009

1,732 sqft, built 2021, in Light Farms The Sage Neighborhood Phase 2. Appraised at $461,154 for 2026.

Collin County account 2827074

Possibly too high

about $14,000

8 similar homes nearby point to a value about $14,000 lower than yours.

Appraised value$461,154
Similar homes$446,907
$14,247 gap · bars start at $0

How sure: High · 8 similar homes (5 shown below) · public records only

Appraised value
$461,154
Tax year 2026
Living area
1,732 sqft
$266 per sqft
Year built
2021
Homestead
Yes
Owner-occupied exemption on file

Why we think so

Unequal assessment

Moderate

8 of 8 similar homes are assessed lower per square foot. Their similarity-weighted median is $253.61/sqft, but land is valued apart from the home, and some of them have less land value per square foot of home than yours, which counts as $155,000. Counting your land in place of theirs where theirs is less, they support a value of $446,907.

Compare this assessment

Start with the county value and property facts, then review appraisal comps, recent sales, and prior-year changes to decide whether the assessment is worth challenging. The comps on this page are free to review; email sign-in is only used to save a printable report.

For nearby context, browse ZIP 75009, Light Farms The Sage Neighborhood Phase 2, Celina, and Prosper assessment pages.

Protest deadline

The 2026 protest deadline was . The 2027 protest deadline is . 2027 notices usually arrive in April.

Deadline rule: May 15, or 30 days after your notice of appraised value is mailed, whichever is later. A deadline on a weekend or holiday moves to the next business day. Evidence is reviewed by the Appraisal Review Board (ARB). Dates checked against the official source.

Assessment snapshot

These public CCAD records highlight what may be worth checking before you file.

  • Assessment changeThe appraised value decreased 0.4% from $462,857 in 2025 to $461,154 in 2026.
  • Appraised value per square footThe current public record shows about $266 per square foot before any comparable-property adjustments.
  • Nearby comparison areaThis page starts the equity review with public records for the Light Farms The Sage Neighborhood Phase 2 neighborhood and ZIP 75009.
  • Neighborhood value signalAmong 752 residential records in the same neighborhood, the average appraised value is about $209 per square foot.
  • Area year-over-year signalNearby residential records with prior-year values moved about -1.7% on average.

Comparable assessments

Showing 5 of the 8 similar homes in this property's equity comparison, from public appraisal records.

  • 525 Smokebrush St, Celina, TX 75009
    1,621 sqft | $266/sqft | built 2016 | 6% smaller (1,621 vs 1,732 sqft); Similar age (2016 vs 2021); Similar lot size (5,905 vs 5,867 sqft)
    $431,444
  • 505 Remington Rd, Celina, TX 75009
    1,827 sqft | $258/sqft | built 2021 | 6% larger (1,827 vs 1,732 sqft); Built same year (2021); Similar lot size (6,281 vs 5,867 sqft)
    $472,251
  • 504 Overton Ave, Celina, TX 75009
    1,848 sqft | $250/sqft | built 2017 | 7% larger (1,848 vs 1,732 sqft); Similar age (2017 vs 2021); Similar lot size (5,725 vs 5,867 sqft)
    $462,735
  • 612 Overton Ave, Celina, TX 75009
    1,826 sqft | $237/sqft | built 2017 | 5% larger (1,826 vs 1,732 sqft); Similar age (2017 vs 2021); Similar lot size (5,584 vs 5,867 sqft)
    $432,500
  • 4132 Lightcreek Ln, Celina, TX 75009
    1,822 sqft | $254/sqft | built 2018 | 5% larger (1,822 vs 1,732 sqft); Similar age (2018 vs 2021); Similar lot size (5,500 vs 5,867 sqft)
    $462,080

Recent comparable sales

Sales selected by similarity to the subject property. Texas is a non-disclosure state, so these MLS-listed sales are supplemental evidence.

  • 2536 Fairweather Dr, Celina, TX 75009
    September-17-2026 | 1,742 sqft | $185/sqft | built 2026 | Similar size (1,742 sqft); Moderate age difference (5 years newer); Sold after the valuation date
    $322,490
  • 1121 Bluebird Way, Celina, TX 75009
    June-10-2026 | 1,761 sqft | $201/sqft | built 2018 | Similar size (1,761 sqft); Similar age (2018); Sold after the valuation date
    $354,000
  • 612 Overton Ave, Celina, TX 75009
    July-21-2026 | 1,829 sqft | $245/sqft | built 2017 | 6% size difference (1,829 sqft); Moderate age difference (4 years older); Sold after the valuation date
    $449,000
  • 4125 Malachite Dr, Celina, TX 75009
    June-15-2026 | 1,668 sqft | $224/sqft | built 2026 | Similar size (1,668 sqft); Moderate age difference (5 years newer); Sold after the valuation date
    $373,974
  • 2517 Pikes Peak Way, Celina, TX 75009
    September-30-2026 | 1,586 sqft | $190/sqft | built 2026 | 8% size difference (1,586 sqft); Moderate age difference (5 years newer); Sold after the valuation date
    $300,990

Public appraisal comparison for 2026. Prepared . Appraisal source: Collin Central Appraisal District. Sales data checked in this snapshot: . Matches consider available size, age, location and property characteristics. How comparisons work.

Value history

Down 0.4% in 2026 from 2025.

Appraised value by tax year, with the change from the previous year listed
Tax yearAppraised valueChangeChange %
2026$461,154−$1,703−0.4%
2025$462,857−$2,115−0.5%
2024$464,972+$2,309+0.5%
2023$462,663+$249,172+116.7%
2022$213,491——
4-year total+$247,663+116.0%